Shoal Lake Snapshots focus on the events of a particular year in Shoal Lake’s history.





Reid Dickie

             In 1884, there wasn’t a village formally known as Shoal Lake quite yet but the newly minted Rural Municipality of Shoal Lake was formed that year, part of the County of Shoal Lake and Russell. John Menzies became the municipality’s first reeve in January 1884, defeating Charles Findlay by five votes. Menzies was re-elected reeve three more times, holding the position non-consecutively until 1906.

North West Mounted Police detachment from The Narrows at the South End.

            Settlement began at The Narrows at the south end of the lake in 1875 when the North West Mounted Police sent a detachment to monitor traffic along the Carlton Trail. This little force with a barracks, stable and guardhouse by a shallow lake planted the seeds of Shoal Lake. It was the town’s genesis.           

North West Mounted Police barracks and stable on the Carlton Trail at the South End of Shoal Lake.

          Once the Police arrived, settlers offered goods and services to support the force that sometimes reached several dozen policemen plus their mounts. An important role for NWMP posts in the fresh West was to act as mail depots. Mail arrived at The Narrows three times a week from Minnedosa, which also had the nearest telegraph, railroad station and express depot.

The Queen's Hotel at the South End.

            By 1884, Henderson’s Directory says the population at The Narrows was 35 people.  The settlement around the NWMP barracks included a public school with one teacher, two hotels – Queen’s Hotel (operated by Graham Chambers and Hugh McKay) and Marshall House (Andrew Marshall’s inn) – two blacksmiths, a pump maker and two general stores – one run by Robert Scott, the other by Thomas Parkinson who was also the postmaster.  Other businesses included two clerks, butcher, livery and feed stable, carpenter and real estate agent.

            Education was available for the children of the pioneers. Edgehill #130 opened in 1881, Culross #185 in 1882 and Raven Lake #287, closest to The Narrows, in 1883.

Shoal Lake entry in 1884 Henderson's Directory for Manitoba and the Northwest Territories.

            The busiest man in the little settlement was A. R. McDougall who was secretary-treasurer of Shoal Lake Municipality, Justice of the Peace (one of two available), issuer of marriage licenses and secretary-treasurer of the Shoal Lake School Division. His homestead was just east of The Narrows.

            A stagecoach line serviced the settlement providing rides and freighting to Minnedosa on Mondays and Fridays, returning the next day. Presbyterian Church services were held every two weeks. Besides the NWMP, a constable maintained law and order.

            Although life was difficult and the amenities spartan, the little cluster of people at the bottleneck on the Carlton Trail foresaw their future among the rolling hills of western Manitoba.

404 words


 Reid Dickie

           The previous year did not end well for Shoal Lake. On Christmas morning 1911, the urgent clanging of the fire bell awakened the citizenry. A fire north of the tracks destroyed several businesses including the Jubilee Hotel, Allan McDonald’s livery barn, Lizett Harness Maker and the Gareau Block, a business and residential building.

            One effect of the blaze was to reaffirm the business section along Station Road while diminishing it north of the tracks. The settlement had first flourished along North Railway Avenue but several disastrous fires provoked the move southward.

            In 1912, according to the provincial directory, 42 Shoal Lake businesses had telephones, of them, 19 were on Station Road. It was an impressive main street for a prairie village. The offices of Dr. W. H. Brothers, Dr. A. Leishman and veterinarian Dr. Robert Lawson opened onto Station Road. On the east corner at The Drive, the new Findlay Block accommodated Charleson’s General Store, W. E. Arens the druggist and Magistrate William Ingersoll.

            Three hardware stores (Eakins and Griffin, Miller and Smellie and J. D. McLean), two general stores (Charleson’s and Smellie Brothers), Cann’s Restaurant, Coulson Jewelers, two solicitors (G. Eakins and Mervyn C. Markle), Findlay Lumber, Keyser the Butcher, and Greenwood & Son Harness, Leather and Shoemaker all operated on Station Road. Burned out in 1911, Frank Miller was rebuilding his block on Station Road. The Masonic Hall (where Choy’s is today), Municipal Office and Union Bank completed the Road.

            The major employer was Shoal Lake Creamery, owned by the Smellie Brothers. Three implement dealers served the growing number of second-generation farmers in the area: J. H. McLean and Kennedy Implements on The Drive and Alexander Menzies on North Railway. There was also Herbert Sykes Livery on Fourth Avenue, Martin Bakery on South Railway, the Star Office on The Drive and two draymen, Bunn and Middleton.

            Lined up along the horizon Shoal Lake had seven elevators with a 1912 capacity well over 200,000 bushels. Five were Manitoba Government elevators, leased to United Grain Growers who only operated three.

            Since the railway provided the main access to Shoal Lake at the time, clustered around the CPR station were the Albion Hotel, Marshall House and, until they burned down, the Jubilee Hotel and Lakeview House.

            The 1912 Shoal Lake phone book listed 170 numbers, 96 in town and 74 farms. The previous year farms started to be connected on a large scale with 67 hooking up.  In town, listings included 53 residences and 43 businesses.

            Village telephone numbers started at 1 and went up from there. Frank Miller’s phone number was 1 since his block housed the telephone office. Rural numbers were on party lines so, in order to know who should answer the call, there was a higher base number, say 114, then ring 13, meaning one long and 3 short rings. If you were “ring 13,” you answered. If you weren’t 13 but snoopy, you might listen in.

            Five years before, the passing of a “benzene buggy” might have elicited cries of “Get a horse!” from bystanders. By 1912, Shoal Lake Municipality, which included Strathclair, Oakburn and Solsgirth, boasted 32 automobiles. An everyday sight, 19 of them were in Shoal Lake, eight in Strathclair, four in Oakburn and one in Solsgirth. 

1912 Manitoba licence plate

           In order to get a driving license, you had to supply a great deal of information about yourself, including full name, birth year and place, marital status, ethnicity, religion, occupation and address. Thanks to the Manitoba Historical Society, I obtained the 1912 list of all the car owners in Shoal Lake Municipality: models, license numbers plus the above information about each.

Complete list of car owners in 1912 in Shoal Lake and district.

            Cars were an obvious status symbol at the time and their owners were the successful elite in the district. Of the 32 cars in the municipality, farmers owned 14 of them, the next largest group was merchants with 6 cars among them. Farmers expressed a strong preference for Ford vehicles. Three lumbermen (all the owners were men), two implement dealers, a bailiff, hotelkeeper, physician, butcher, baker and livery operator owned the rest. The average owner’s age was just over 40 with the youngest driver being 22 and the oldest 61.

            The most popular model was Ford, not surprising since Shoal Lake had a large Ford dealership on The Drive run by Wicks and Kennedy. Of the 32 cars, eleven were Fords, six were EMFs (Everitt, Metzer and Flanders), five were McLaughlins, with two Overlands, two Cadillacs and two Regals. As well, there was a Tudhope, a Reo, an International and a Mitchell. The only person to own more than one car was Oakburn storekeeper Donald A. Menzies who owned two Cadillacs.

Fourteen of Shoal Lake's car owners in 1913. This picture of the local automobile club was taken on Station Road.

            Presbyterians were most likely to be car owners (they tended to drive McLaughlins). Anglicans and Methodists were next with a couple of Baptists tempted as well. Scotsmen, listed as “Scotch”, owned the most cars followed by Englishman, Germans and Irish. Most of the drivers were married with six single men and two widowers also reported.

            In the early 1900s, there was influx of young people from Ontario. Many had sought farms there but arable land was at a premium. Most of it had been bought up and was under cultivation. Many second or third generation Ontario farmers headed west to seek their own farmland. Sixteen of Shoal Lake car owners were born in Ontario. Five Brits and 5 Manitobans were next with Scotland, U.S.A. and New Brunswick filling in the rest. Vehicles licenses were sequential using only numerals. Shoal Lake municipality license numbers ranged between 224 (James McTavish’s McLaughlin) and 3805 (Daniel McMurachy’s Ford).

            Shoal Lake’s 1912 population was about 700 people. The political landscape saw William J. Short as Reeve and Alfred S. Arnold as mayor, his second non-consecutive term. The newly incorporated village had a different mayor every year from its inception in 1909 until 1913 when Frederick W. Wicks, co-owner of the Ford dealership, won election and held the position until 1919. Long serving Frank Dodds was secretary for the municipality, village and agricultural society. The postmaster was E. C. Castell.

            One of the pressing issues village council needed to address in 1912 was a new town hall for the freshly designated community. They tried to pass a by-law to create the building but it needed to be legalized by the Law Amendments Committee of the Local Legislature. Though there was some opposition, the bill passed with help from Huntley Malcolm, M. P. P. and the local council. The council opted to build on the site of the small and inadequate municipal office at Station Road and The Drive.

After some political manouvering, Shoal Lake's new town hall rose at the corner of Station Road and The Drive in 1913.

            Other noteworthy events in 1912 included council setting the village tax rate at 30 mills on the dollar. Shoal Lake’s first school newspaper came out in 1912, edited by the senior class. Mayor Arnold had the first electrical system in town installed in his house.

            In 1912, the Dominion of Canada purchased seed grain from several local farmers – William Short, Fred Findlay, Frank Wherrett, Alfred Nicholson and John Hurst – because it had been highly praised for its cleanliness by the government inspector.

            In April, many of the churches held services mourning the huge loss of life when the Titanic sank. Shoal Lake Star Editor H. J. Newman was moved to comment, “The bravery of the men who obeyed the ‘women first’ rule on the lost Titanic is the brightest ray which has pierced the dark cloud which hangs over the Newfoundland Banks.”

            Summer in early Shoal Lake offered many diversions for young and old with the summer fair, chautauqua and, in the first week of July, the annual Grain Grower’s Picnic. The winter of 1912 kicked off carnivals, ice fishing and the Shoal Lake hockey team’s season.

            One oddity about 1912: there were 38 births in the village and municipality of Shoal Lake in the first six months of 1913. A virtual baby boom!

            In 1913, the Shoal Lake hockey team’s winning streak took them all the way to the provincial amateur championship beating Brandon for the title. At a cost of $11, 850, council hired Edward Snider to build the new town hall, a very distinguished stately building for a small village. (Shoal Lake’s third town hall stands on the same site.) In a move of grand foresight, council also passed a money by-law for $15,000 to install an electric light plant to serve the village with hydro. The plant building still stands behind the town hall and has served in many capacities over the decades. The lights went on in Shoal Lake and so did life.

1466 words



Reid Dickie

            As 1960 ended, the topics Shoal Lakers debated over coffee at Patterson’s Grill and Gim’s Café included the Smellie Brothers selling the creamery to ManCo, the Mounties starting to use radar to catch speeders and whether or not to become “a village with water.” That meant spending $199,000 to bring water and sewer service to a good portion of the community.

Above the fold

Below the fold of the special edition of The Shoal Lake Star on December 29,1960. Note it was published for the Civic Betterment Committee with emphasis on modernity.

            In a special edition of The Shoal Lake Star, devoted completely to the waterworks issue and published a week before the referendum on January 6, 1961, Mayor Cassel Snyder wrote a long piece supporting the plan. Snyder touted the benefits as bringing industry to the town, lowering insurance rates while raising property values, encouraging people to build new houses in town and bringing local sanitation into the 20th century. A well-attended public meeting in the town hall on January 4 convinced people, resulting in a positive outcome for the plan. (The new water and sewer system was a deciding factor in my family building a house on Fourth Avenue in 1962.)

             The Shoal Lake Hospital received a grant for $15,120 to convert to the new water and sewer system. By June, the trenching to install the pipes was underway all over town. Star editor Elgin Hurst commented that after a long hot summer much of the community could look forward to “the first winter not having to make unpleasant trips to the town well or even more unpleasant journeys to the backyard.” By fall, a majority of the homes in Shoal Lake had hot and cold running water and flush toilets. The outhouse was on the way out.

            Typically, towns with newly opened waterworks commemorate the event with a biffy burning. While some places gathered dozens of outhouses into a pile for burning, Shoal Lake took the more symbolic path, burning just one biffy in the park at a well-attended and joyous ceremony in the fall of 1961.

            Voters returned to decide in another referendum on March 6, 1961, this time regarding a debenture of $140,000 to build a new eight-room elementary school plus an auditorium. On March 3, the Shoal Lake Star published another special issue with Mayor Snyder, Chairman of the Civic Betterment Committee C. W. McLean, Reeve Mike Antonation and R. B. Stevenson, Chairman of the Shoal Lake Consolidated School Board writing in support of the spending. They needn’t have worried. The by-law easily passed 360 for, 20 against. Construction began and, before the Christmas holiday closure, classes were being held in the new building.

Extra edition of The Shoal Lake Star published March 3, 1961 supporting building the new elementary school.

            The Shoal Lake Figuring Skating Club gave its first performance at the 1961 ice carnival. That spring the town’s first sportsman’s dinner was held, honouring Winnipeg Blue Bomber Joe Zaleski, Chicago Black Hawk Billy Mosienko and baseball coach Curly Hass.

            In 1961, the biggest day of the week in Shoal Lake was Saturdays, especially Saturday nights. Farms families came to town on Saturday night to shop, go to the movies, attend a wedding, knock back a few at the hotel, gossip or just generally enjoy the company. Parked vehicles lined Station Road all day and all night on Saturdays. By 1961, after decades of trying to get motorists to park at a 45-degree angle, drivers got the hang of it, making parking somewhat less chaotic on Saturday nights.

            The new elementary school and newly renovated high school (the red brick building) had their official openings in 1962. Business growth included four new rooms at Hunter’s Paradise Motel; Shust Motors added an auto body repair and paint shop and Snyder’s Hardware completed their warehouse facilities.

            In 1962, the Shoal Lake Improvement Association formed to expedite expanding the park and recreation facilities in the town and district. The Lions’ Club started construction of the 800-foot dam spanning the lake in September and installing a pumping station, at a cost of about $1700.

            The outcomes of the two 1961 referendums and the other Shoal Lake initiatives, while having obvious and needed benefits for the community, also reflect a sense of optimism, which ignited as the 1960s began and flourished as the decade proceeded.

679 words


7 Responses to Snapshots

  1. Bea says:

    James Nelson Westover married Ada Laughton Chaple both born at Shoal Lake, Manitoba, Canada and later married
    Is there any records on James & Ada Westover, they had two daughter born at Shoal Lake, Manitoba
    They lived about five or six miles out of town and went to school by horse and buggy.

    When it snowed they stayed home. “The roads were always cleared for their Christmas concert.
    They would be given parts to learn at home and Ada would teach the girls their recitation.



    • readreidread says:

      Hello Bea, Thanks for checking out the SL history blog and for your inquiry about your family. I have come up with a few Westovers for you. The earliest one is Calvin Westover who appears in the Henderson’s Directory in 1901 for the first time. Calvin was a drayman then in 1902 he was proprietor of the Lakeview Hotel seemingly for a short time. In the 1918 phone directory there is a C. Westover at NE 12-16-23 that could be Calvin. Thereafter I lose track of Calvin unless he is the John C. Westover in SL Cemetery, died Oct. 22, 1920 at 67 years 7 months. One other Westover is buried in SL Cemetery: Sarah, died Feb. 16, 1896 at 38 years.
      The reference I found for your Westovers is from the 1918 SL telephone directory that lists J. N. Westover on a farm located NE 14-18-23. The family was on a party line and their number was 132 ring 2. That’s all I got. Maybe one of our readers can supply more information. I had a feeling there was Westovers in Strathclair, just down the road from SL but their history book turned up nothing. I hope that is some help to you. Warm regards, Reid


  2. Lisa Stepp says:

    Interesting about the hockey team, Heather. My grandfather’s cousin, Fred Olsen, played on Winnipeg’s Icelandic hockey team, The Vikings, around 1898. I see Fred Olsen is in the 1921 census at Shoal Lake. Just wondering if he might have been on the Shoal Lake team, or perhaps one of his sons was, because he would be pushing 40 at that time.


  3. i would like to have information in regards to the kelloe school, in about 1934 /38 a teacher that was there at the time was miss stevenson if someone would let me know thanks dorothy


    • readreidread says:

      Hi Dorothy, Going by SL’s history book Ripples on the Lake, Kelloe School #574 you are referring to was built in 1928. In 1964 the school at Kelloe closed. The building is now situated on a farm at Foxwarren. Anyone else got anything about Kelloe School for Dorothy? Reid


  4. Heather Badger Koch says:

    I have been researching the Shoal Lake Hockey team for my father, William Badger, 87 years who was born in Shoal Lake. Do you know the names of the men on the team? He believes he worked for one Eddie Arnold. Dad is currently living in Calif. but is very nostalgic for his home. He was the boy in the 30’s who was rescued from Shoal Lake. He and his brother Dougie nearly drowned near the creamery.


    • readreidread says:

      Hello Heather,

      Thanks for getting in touch. Funny how little towns have a magnetic attraction that lures people back, if not in person then in memory and in nostalgia. I remember reading the story of Bill and Dougie almost drowning in the lake. It’s recounted in Ripples on the Lake history book. Did Doug die in WWII? I couldn’t come up with any hockey rosters for you. Eddie Arnold farmed anbd breed heavy horses near Shoal Lake for decades so it is likely your grandpa worked for him. Maybe a blog reader will have more information for you. All the best, Reid


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s